Illogicopedia:Review/HowTo:Go on IRC
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
- See here for the review index.
HowTo:Go on IRC[edit | edit source]
Ljlego 21:54, 28 Farbleum 2008 (UTC)
| Concept: | 8 | A questionable guide for a sensible subject; good. |
| Execution: | 6 | The confusion and questionableness is good, but the insulting parts are a bit too plain. Reducing harshness a bit, replacing it with nutty suggestions for self-improvement ("Message yourself three times, and you'll instantly become better. What, it didn't work!?"), or otherwise making them more nonsensical would serve to increase the "WTF?"-factor of the guide. |
| Grammar and Formatting: | 8 | Just fine. |
| Images: | 0 | None, so not applicable. |
| Miscellany: | 7 | Overall, a little too un-strange, I think; weirding it up a bit would add that nonsense edge. |
| Final Score: | 29 | Good potential; if it were less sane, I'd vote for it for feature. |
| Reviewer: | Fluffalizer 00:51, 4 Arche 2008 (UTC) | |
Random idea: For additional confusion, a "noob" could first be described as a good thing to be ("Non-objectionable", perhaps?), and then suddenly things go wrong and it is bad!. Fluffalizer 00:51, 4 Arche 2008 (UTC)