Illogicopedia:Review/Roy G. Biv

From Illogicopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
See here for the review index.

Roy G. Biv[edit | edit source]

I rewrote this article. Hindles gave me a nice comment, and I was wondering what ou, yes, YOU think. —rms talk 04:22, 17 Yoon 2009 (UTC)

Concept: 9 I think it is a brilliant idea to write about an "actor" who never made it in showbiz as thought he is aclaimed
Execution: 7 I brought this down because there are times when the language breaks down in places, it needs to be kept more formal than it is, since with formality comes believablility. I did like the gradual slide into understanding of who roy G biv is, it was like a striptease, i was compelled to read more.
Grammar and Formatting: 9 I'm terrible with this, so i cant comment.
Images: 8 The images themselves are great, some of them might need their levels adjusted slightly too make it bright but dreary, again, the captions are a bit on the informal or obvious side, try improving their language, or adding in a joke.
Miscellany: 10 N/A
Final Score: 43 I think the most important thing you have missed is some of the language, other than that, it was great. Well done.
Reviewer: --Silent Penguin 11:32, 17 Yoon 2009 (UTC)


Hey, thanks, Seppy! I'm glad you enjoyed it. —rms talk 16:34, 17 Yoon 2009 (UTC)