Illogicopedia:Review/Trains

From Illogicopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
See here for the review index.

Trains[edit | edit source]

~ 04:49, 13 Aym 2009 (UTC)


Concept: 5 Nothing too special but nothing bad either.
Execution: 3.14159265 Kinda seemed like just half-jokes and build that amounted to nothing. (LOLZ! I WROTE PI!)
Grammar and Formatting: 8 Not story or listy. Hence 8.
Images: 8 Rough and pantified but kinda funny and they get the job done.
Miscellany: .2 Just so you don't think it's good.
Final Score: 24.34159265 RMS, I like your good stuff and this isn't one of the good stuff.
Reviewer: T3 20:14, 16 Aym 2009 (UTC)



Concept: 5 Well, it's a random rant on trains, Illogicopedia style.
Execution: 5 Fairly well-structured nonsense, not the best, but alright.
Grammar and Formatting: 8 Can't really fault it too much.
Images: 6.5 I shall take a cropping hammer to the pics for you.
Miscellany: 7 Fnargleflex. Anyhow, it's a solid article. Probably never going to be featureable I think, because it lacks a central 'idea', a spark, a specific direction. As it is, though, it's OK.
Final Score: 31.5 Like I said, I'll take a look at those pics for you.
Reviewer: Hindleyak  Converse?blogClick here! 16:30, 18 Aym 2009 (UTC)