Illogicopedia:VFF/Seven hells

From Illogicopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
The voting below has ended, the result decided; save commenting, do not edit it.

Seven hells

Score: -2 (2-4) Nomination by PiddlerOfTrousers approves this article (talk) 15:36, 22 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • Agin - It is pretty illogical, so points for that. However, it's not feature-worthy because it's not outstanding in any sense. One solid criticism: it's derivative with references to common and overused ?llogia words like "cheese", "penguin", etc.. Also, self-nomming an article is kinda bad form. I wouldn't forbid it, but in this case, where you've done two in a row and neither is really nomable as is, well... DO NOT take any of this as negatively personal, but as loving, constructive criticism by a giblet head. Cheers! LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 04:17, 8 Ergust 2015 (UTC)
  • Noot gooed oonooth There's a certain theme on this site to write intentionally random things on this site and it never works out. Heck, I do it sometimes, but a good article needs to have some sort of 'reality' and a small dab of seriousness around it; my thoughts are as above, randomly using words like "cheese" and "penguin" for their own purposes isn't funny for me. Monkey-butler.jpg Sincerely, islandmonkey - go speak 17:33, 17 Ergust 2015 (UTC)
  • NO! Why is this even a thing?
    --The previous unsigned comment was left by (talk), see the past frenzies page for posting time
  • It's ok, but it's not something enough. What everybody else said.  Flyingcat (meow?)fr: 18:42, 8 Jumbly 2018 (UTC)
  • It's OK, but it needs more 'zazz for feature quality. More categories, for starters. Maybe some fresh ginger and garlic? LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 00:32, 24 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • I liked it all except the lack of 'zazz mentioned above. Also as much as I love downright vanity I am a little hesitant to vote for on an article with such blatant self reference. Might be alone on such an opinion... but that's what I think.--Duckwiki2.png|Fonchezzz| Quacking| 18:24, 24 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • In response to you, I was ridiculously vain as a joke. Nothing like self-deprivating humor to lighten the heart! ☃☃☃ (talk) 22:18, 24 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
You meant to say self-deprecating. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 04:17, 8 Ergust 2015 (UTC)
  • Hahaha no I feel ya. Self reference isn't necessarily bad at all (like i said, I do it all the time)- I dunno maybe it could just be approached a little more subtly.--Duckwiki2.png|Fonchezzz| Quacking| 12:28, 25 Yoon 2015 (UTC)

Back to VFF