Illogicopedia:Votes for Feature

From Illogicopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
This is for articles; see also: Illogicopedia:Featured images
Sencible stamp.png
  This section is Logical; it is meant to be. Prepare to be bored.  
  Sensible Section  


This page displays of all the current votes. See Forum:Department of Limelight for a summary index of nominated articles and the other non-article-vote-related things handled there.

Previous article nominations can be found here - or separately, the featured, the ones waiting to be featured and the ones that failed. This category tree also contains all nominated pages and their votes. (useful for checking that the VFF template has been added/removed correctly)

Nomination

Enter the full name of the article below (make sure to use proper capitalization) and click "Nominate", then follow the instructions on the next page to create the entry. If the page already exists, you can either try to fix the "Revoting" option or give up.

Revolting

If you think a previously failed nomination has a chance at winning a revote, you can re-nominate it below. (note that repeated renomination of a page without good reason is frowned upon – a review of the article is recommended) Once again, enter the full name of the article below (make sure to use proper capitalization) and click "Revote", then follow the instructions on the next page to create the entry.

Current votes

VOTING REGULATIONS
There is voting currently taking place below this template, So here are the voting basics:
  • Users are permitted one vote each.
  • Please clearly state whether your addition is a for, an against or a comment.
  • Remember to sign and to update the vote count.
  • Nominations count as a vote for unless specified as "Neutral" or "Against".
  • Take care not to overdo self-nomination.
  • If you wish to change your vote, then cross out the previous using the <s> tags.
  • Frog-infested pineapples are not allowed in the voting area until they have been de-frogged.
Click here for more details





Editing under the influence (vote)

Score: 3 (5-2) Nomination by Snarglefoop (talk) 02:10, 10 Farbleum 2014 (UTC)
For:
  • For Such a precise, dryly realistic portrayal of Wikipedia blocking policy in action surely deserves to be highlighted featured Snarglefoop (talk) 02:10, 10 Farbleum 2014 (UTC)
  • Self-for can I vote for it please? Even though I'm not a rollbacker? -− Flyingcat (meow?)fr: 02:12, 10 Farbleum 2014 (UTC)
  • For - Like it, like it, like it. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 14:11, 4 Jeremy 2016 (UTC)
  • For simsilikesims (talk) 23:58, 19 Octodest 2016 (UTC)
  • For. Also, am I allowed to add this to the Madness category? felis lupis (talk) 20:48, 23 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)
Sure. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 01:10, 24 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)
Against:
  • I'm so, so sorry. I put off voting on this just so I didn't have to make this decision. --T3 04:07, 7 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
    Why are you sorry? It's just an article. -− Flyingcat (meow?)fr: 04:14, 7 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
    I am "sorry" because I hate voting against articles that technically have nothing wrong with them, but I just don't like enough to vote "For" on. Additionally, I am an overly-apologetic person, and I put the two "so's" so it sounds like the Tenth Doctor, which is a reference I only made for my amusement. --T3 06:14, 7 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
    Nope.avi Icons-flag-au.png Operator XY - (Conversal :: Editations - Special:Editcount/XY007 and counting!) 7-12-15
Comments:
  • Hey! It's got an image now! Can I vote for it a second time, since this makes it sort of different and stuff? Snarglefoop (talk) 23:33, 22 Farbleum 2014 (UTC)


Hypostatic Precambrianism (vote)

Score: 4 (4.00000-0) Nomination by Snarglefoop (talk) 03:37, 4 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)
For:
  • 4) It's one of the most apparently erudite articles I've ever seen anywhere.
    Plus, it's got a senseless reference to whatsisname who didn't paint pipes.
    Plus, it's got a cat. Snarglefoop (talk) 03:37, 4 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)
  • Interdisciplinary illogic. Cg098 (talk) 22:04, 4 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)
  • I like the co-muscular dirigibles of the cheese. Icons-flag-au.png Operator XY - (Conversal :: Editations - Special:Editcount/XY007 and counting!) 08:03, 5 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)
  • Because trilobites are early Cambrian. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 22:00, 5 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:


User is blocked (vote)

Score: 1 (1-0) Nomination by Icons-flag-au.png Operator XY - (Conversal :: Editations - Special:Editcount/XY007 and counting!) 03:50, 24 Jeremy 2016 (UTC)
For:

User is blocked because they spent $967 on room service. --Icons-flag-au.png Operator XY - (Conversal :: Editations - Special:Editcount/XY007 and counting!) 03:50, 24 Jeremy 2016 (UTC)

Against:
Comments:

I hope there's at least one person who gets that reference. Icons-flag-au.png Operator XY - (Conversal :: Editations - Special:Editcount/XY007 and counting!) 21:45, 24 Jeremy 2016 (UTC)

Whoever they are who got the reference, it wasn't me. Snarglefoop (talk) 03:53, 4 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)
  • Found some things confusing. Snarglefoop (talk) 03:53, 4 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)
  1. What does this mean? " and what we're trying to do here" I mean, what are we trying to do here? Does anyone know?
    1. Ill tell you what. We're trying to be like Hank Hill in the show King Of The Hill. We're trying to inject anti-sanctimonious propaganda into sub stream media, generating a worldwide current of -really-scaly-tic- nattering. 21:53, 5 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)
  2. Why are there two of this article, one with a capital 'B'?
This looks like it was spooned from Uncyclopedia. Uncyclopedia may have an agenda, but I don't think we do. Cg098 (talk) 22:02, 4 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)

I am also confused. On the face of it, this article doesn't belong here. Can't decide how to vote on this one yet. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 21:53, 5 Farbleum 2017 (UTC)


This Page is Useless (vote)

Score: 2 (2-0) Nomination by simsilikesims (talk) 23:56, 19 Octodest 2016 (UTC)
For:
  1. For simsilikesims (talk) 23:56, 19 Octodest 2016 (UTC)
  2. Let's go with that Icons-flag-au.png Operator XY - (Conversal :: Editations - Special:Editcount/XY007 and counting!) 08:39, 1 Novelniver 2016 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:


Foals (vote)

Score: 2 (3-1) Nomination by 2+2=5 SPEAK TO ME, ILLOGIAN! Past accounts of sodomy RAVENOUS AND RUTHLESS CAPITALISM The greatest article in the history of Illogia! 03:05, 18 Aym 2016 (UTC)
For:
  • FOAL because I think this is legit Feature material. For once I racked my brain for pure illogic and poured it out on this piece of snot. 2+2=5 SPEAK TO ME, ILLOGIAN! Past accounts of sodomy RAVENOUS AND RUTHLESS CAPITALISM The greatest article in the history of Illogia! 03:05, 18 Aym 2016 (UTC)
  • So-li-ci-ta-tion! Icons-flag-au.png Operator XY - (Conversal :: Editations - Special:Editcount/XY007 and counting!) 05:56, 18 Aym 2016 (UTC)
  • Four because Grumpled oops Gruntled sounds so sad about it on his talk page, maybe another vote will cheer him up. And besides, it's got penguins. (And there are four three votes four, not two, so why weren't they all being counted? What, the Illuminati opposed it or something?) Snarglefoop (talk) 20:25, 7 Serpeniver 2016 (UTC)
Against:
  • Well you asked me to vote for it but didn't specify how to vote exactly. I apologise; as reimbursement, I will give you twenty pounds Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 05:15, 18 Aym 2016 (UTC)
Comments:
  • Yes, I'm into this band, Mr. de Singe.
  • Also, what the heck Mr. Decks? Asking someone to vote is as straightforward as it gets... unless you're in the USA like me... and twenty pounds? I ought to buy a $15 iTunes gift card with that. 2+2=5 SPEAK TO ME, ILLOGIAN! Past accounts of sodomy RAVENOUS AND RUTHLESS CAPITALISM The greatest article in the history of Illogia! 01:00, 24 Aym 2016 (UTC)
  • Undecision It has le madness and le ngth is good as well, but it doesn't exactly stand out and I don't even know what this is. --Kuu-olio,oi!_Nenä. (bamla) 14:11, 18 Aym 2016 (UTC)


Haiku (vote)

Score: 5 (5-0) Nomination by XY007 T C 23:54, 20 Arche 2015 (UTC)
For:
  • Nom and for I know, this article is so good, it should be featured XY007 T C 23:54, 20 Arche 2015 (UTC)
  • Schmanky - Ahhhhhh! Real Monsters! LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 17:11, 13 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • I will vote for this.
    It should be on the front page.
    With a seasonal theme. --Nerd42 (talk) 01:15, 19 Ergust 2015 (UTC)
  • For --(BKYE) Sophia, The Resident Uncyclopedia Deity (talk) 00:10, 21 Jeremy 2016 (UTC)
  • For. Also: Nerd42's haiku is done incorrectly. "With a sea-son-al theme" is 6 syllables. Eidos! 2+2=5 SPEAK TO ME, ILLOGIAN! Past accounts of sodomy RAVENOUS AND RUTHLESS CAPITALISM The greatest article in the history of Illogia! 20:12, 29 Aym 2016 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:

WE IS ACTIVE AGAIN! The Supreme Leader XY --- Free Cake! 07:29, 19 Ergust 2015 (UTC)


Avril Lavigne Reference Desk (vote)

Score: 1 (1-0) Nomination by Icons-flag-au.png Operator XY - (Conversal :: Editations - Special:Editcount/XY007 and counting!) 01:00, 6 Arche 2016 (UTC)
For:

Sid Meier's Alpha Centauri I quite like this article. Though it'd be best served renaming it to Avril Lavigne and Summer Glau Reference Desk. This ends the pre-recorded message by Icons-flag-au.png Operator XY - (Conversal :: Editations - Special:Editcount/XY007 and counting!) 01:00, 6 Arche 2016 (UTC)

Against:
Comments:


Fake announcer voice (vote)

Score: 3 (3-0) Nomination by Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 13:57, 7 Ergust 2015 (UTC)
For:
Against:
Comments:
  • Good humour and beautiful formatting. Illogicopedia sure has had its morning. Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 13:57, 7 Ergust 2015 (UTC)


Good electricity and bad electricity (vote)

Score: 1 (1-0) Nomination by LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 15:40, 4 Jeremy 2016 (UTC)
For:
  • For - A dazzling surreal dip into the story of elextrikity. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 15:40, 4 Jeremy 2016 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:


The article that's hard to edit (vote)

Score: 0 (5-5) Nomination by Nerd42 (talk) 19:46, 17 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
For:
  • feature this. --Nerd42 (talk) 19:46, 17 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
  • Yeah. This article is totally WTF IMHO OSIA... Snarglefoop (talk) 04:34, 8 Serpeniver 2014 (UTC)
  • Good87.64.160.159 14:19, 8 Farbleum 2015 (UTC)
  • For When Flutter actually writes an article! The Supreme Leader XY --- Free Cake! 05:47, 24 Serpeniver 2015 (UTC)
  • For. MyNameIsLuis Philippines (talkcontribsguestbookuncyc) 10:30, 3 Novelniver 2015 (UTC)
  • For - I feel strongly that this article represents our pedia really well. The dinosaurs missed their chance to create such a piece of illogic. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 14:16, 4 Jeremy 2016 (UTC)
Against:
  • I know this is kind of the point but this one makes my eyes bleed. Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 01:21, 18 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
  • I thought about it more, and realized that not supporting it for feature is definitely sufficient reason to vote against. --T3 03:07, 18 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
  • While I admire Flutter's extensive knowledge of Unicode characters, I'm afraid I'd rather not support something that's hard to read. Sorry to pile on. -− Flyingcat (meow?)fr: 16:25, 21 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
  • Negatory m'lords. not a thing that should be on the front page.--Duckwiki2.png|Fonchezzz| Quacking| 13:49, 24 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
  • meh pff, even i agree its not a pretty sight (oviously), but very considerate that someone cared for it to be nommed,... and look at that flyinCat fellow, bro sounds lik it knows me or sum biz —Flutter ₧s: over 9000 clap.gif 04:07, 31 Ergust 2014 (EDT)
Comments:
  • Abstain because I really don't support it for feature, but it is hard to edit, so it isn't really lying. --T3 20:02, 17 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)


Extreme wingnuttery (vote)

Score: 2 (3-1) Nomination by Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 06:21, 17 Yoon 2014 (UTC)
For:
  • Short yet sweet, plus I liked this one for quite a while. You want to polish the floor? Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 06:21, 17 Yoon 2014 (UTC)
  • Nutter extremewingy -− Flyingcat (meow?)fr: 20:21, 17 Yoon 2014 (UTC)
  • This article is a coded signal by aliens, 000300. The Supreme Leader XY --- Free Cake! 23:23, 20 Octodest 2015 (UTC)
Against:
  • Definite against --T3 06:54, 4 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
Comments:


Dear vet, why has my pet rabbit grown wings and a propeller (vote)

Score: 2 (2-0) Nomination by Monkey-butler.jpg Sincerely, islandmonkey - go speak 19:02, 8 Ergust 2015 (UTC)
For:

Self-onomonom. Monkey-butler.jpg Sincerely, islandmonkey - go speak 19:02, 8 Ergust 2015 (UTC)

Against:
Comments:

Disclaimer -- I did not take anything to make this, and I have not done anything before or plan to. Story + phase of using drugs for names of people, that's all. Monkey-butler.jpg Sincerely, islandmonkey - go speak 16:27, 24 Serpeniver 2015 (UTC)


CNN (vote)

Score: 2 (2-0) Nomination by Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 14:14, 18 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
For:
  • Nom and for, quality entertainment. Also in it for the Chaser reference and the unlikely notion that Mishtemon might come back here if his article gets featured. Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 14:14, 18 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • For That's Numbermink! The Supreme Leader XY --- Free Cake! 04:52, 10 Serpeniver 2015 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:
  • Whoa, about two minutes later I realised how impulsive of a decision this nomination was, and am starting to reconsider. This article does have a lot of useless numbers after all. I mainly voted for the 'shows' section. Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 14:18, 18 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • Yeah, it's OK, but maybe not VFF quality. If you're going to try upgrading it, we can just remove it from VFF until you deem it ready. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 14:36, 18 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • Too...many...numbers... :D Monkey-butler.jpg Sincerely, islandmonkey - go speak 18:17, 17 Ergust 2015 (UTC)


Spaghetti (vote)

Score: 3 (4-1) Nomination by LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 19:04, 10 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
For:
  • fury - A fine piece of batshittery. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 19:04, 10 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • Oh dear, what an unexpected development. Self-disfigurement Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 09:11, 11 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • It was a goof!--Duckwiki2.png|Fonchezzz| Quacking| 12:55, 25 Ergust 2015 (UTC)
  • Fury spells a sweet victory of the pink Lickitung. The Supreme Leader XY --- Free Cake! 04:51, 10 Serpeniver 2015 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:


Evil laughter (vote)

Score: 1 (3-2) Nomination by Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 07:23, 1 Octodest 2014 (UTC)
For:
  • Whilst I used to only remember this as that article I added a terrible image to all that time ago, I had another read through and realised Dxpenguinman seems to have a knack for writing brilliance. Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 07:23, 1 Octodest 2014 (UTC)
  • I just like it. Iamawesome  T | C | U  17:04, 25 Arche 2015 (UTC)
  • Finnország Quite good actually. The Supreme Leader XY --- Free Cake! 11:24, 21 Ergust 2015 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:


Seven hells (vote)

Score: 0 (2-2) Nomination by PiddlerOfTrousers approves this article (talk) 15:36, 22 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
For:
Against:
  • Agin - It is pretty illogical, so points for that. However, it's not feature-worthy because it's not outstanding in any sense. One solid criticism: it's derivative with references to common and overused ?llogia words like "cheese", "penguin", etc.. Also, self-nomming an article is kinda bad form. I wouldn't forbid it, but in this case, where you've done two in a row and neither is really nomable as is, well... DO NOT take any of this as negatively personal, but as loving, constructive criticism by a giblet head. Cheers! LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 04:17, 8 Ergust 2015 (UTC)
  • Noot gooed oonooth There's a certain theme on this site to write intentionally random things on this site and it never works out. Heck, I do it sometimes, but a good article needs to have some sort of 'reality' and a small dab of seriousness around it; my thoughts are as above, randomly using words like "cheese" and "penguin" for their own purposes isn't funny for me. Monkey-butler.jpg Sincerely, islandmonkey - go speak 17:33, 17 Ergust 2015 (UTC)
Comments:
  • It's OK, but it needs more 'zazz for feature quality. More categories, for starters. Maybe some fresh ginger and garlic? LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 00:32, 24 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • I liked it all except the lack of 'zazz mentioned above. Also as much as I love downright vanity I am a little hesitant to vote for on an article with such blatant self reference. Might be alone on such an opinion... but that's what I think.--Duckwiki2.png|Fonchezzz| Quacking| 18:24, 24 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • In response to you, I was ridiculously vain as a joke. Nothing like self-deprivating humor to lighten the heart! ☃☃☃ (talk) 22:18, 24 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
You meant to say self-deprecating. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 04:17, 8 Ergust 2015 (UTC)
  • Hahaha no I feel ya. Self reference isn't necessarily bad at all (like i said, I do it all the time)- I dunno maybe it could just be approached a little more subtly.--Duckwiki2.png|Fonchezzz| Quacking| 12:28, 25 Yoon 2015 (UTC)


Martian Luther (vote)

Score: 1 (2-1) Nomination by LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 04:06, 14 Jumbly 2015 (UTC)
For:
  • Fyur Possibly the most clever single sentence in IllogiLand. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 04:06, 14 Jumbly 2015 (UTC)
  • Fire Yes. It's short, and it's sweet, just like F*** and Is. XY007talkcontributions 06:09, 14 Jumbly 2015 (UTC)
Against:
  • no thx I love it, but I am hesitant about throwing 1 liners on the front page.--Duckwiki2.png|Fonchezzz| Quacking| 12:41, 31 Jumbly 2015 (UTC)
Comments:
  • Fonch - I understand your reticence about one liners. May I sway you with pomegranates and that here on our silly wiki, the otherwise unseemly is sometimes encouraged. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 16:01, 31 Jumbly 2015 (UTC)
  • Have I been accused of rational thinking? By Garlic and by The Seven Seas, what has become of me? Have I become a monster?--Duckwiki2.png|Fonchezzz| Quacking| 18:19, 31 Jumbly 2015 (UTC)


Days like these (vote)

Score: 0 (2-2) Nomination by Monkey-butler.jpg Sincerely, islandmonkey - go speak 13:21, 6 Arply 2015 (UTC)
For:
  • Aye. While not funny, I find this article beautiful. It's a gem and I know where it deserves to go. Monkey-butler.jpg Sincerely, islandmonkey - go speak 13:21, 6 Arply 2015 (UTC)
  • Narf - New from Whammo! LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 16:59, 13 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:

I can't decide. Could I get a side of fried dumplings-ish? Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 08:38, 27 Yoon 2015 (UTC)


Radiohead (vote)

Score: 2 (4-2) Nomination by Twoandtwoalwaysmakesafive (talk) 22:45, 12 Arply 2015 (UTC)User:Twoandtwoalwaysmakesafive
For:
  • For because Radiohead changed my life. User:Twoandtwoalwaysmakesafive
  • It's pretty good, I mean, it was a stub which was in need of expansion and I reckon 2+2 did a decent job at it. Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 03:48, 14 Arply 2015 (UTC)
  • Multo bene - Norepinephrine. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 15:27, 8 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • Much Yes--Duckwiki2.png|Fonchezzz| Quacking| 19:02, 24 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:

seriously? "an old meme?" That's mean. >:( I know I mention them a lot (often times in an annoying matter), but when you're a diehard fanatic of something, you can never stop. If you can, please reconsider. User:Twoandtwoalwaysmakesafive

I'm sorry I just don't like it. XY007talkcontributions 07:32, 14 Arply 2015 (UTC)


Tvtropes (vote)

Score: 3 (3-0) Nomination by Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 09:44, 16 Farbleum 2015 (UTC)
For:
  • Thing I found ages ago that I forgot to actually nom/for. Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 09:44, 16 Farbleum 2015 (UTC)
  • Worthy LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png(kaizum me)Plant2.png 17:17, 13 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • Foor Wanted to do a big expansion on it, but then Roberto beat me to it. XY007talkcontributions 23:15, 13 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:


Watafakkism (vote)

Score: 3 (3-0) Nomination by Synanim1.gif Twoandtwoalwaysmakesafive Synanim1.gif (Break my front door down.) Synanim1.gif 20:12, 9 Aym 2015 (UTC)
For:
Against:
Comments:


Singular Ways to Die (vote)

Score: 3 (3-0) Nomination by XY007talkcontributions 01:08, 26 Aym 2015 (UTC)
For:
  • Nom and phor Nice nice nice. XY007talkcontributions 01:08, 26 Aym 2015 (UTC)
  • Brilliant - I couldn't stop farting. LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png 01:40, 6 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
  • Eventual inevitable self-for primarily because I'd like to see a potato named Calamity on the front page. Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 05:41, 6 Yoon 2015 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:


The Normal Case of Benjamin's Butt on... (vote)

Score: 2 (2-0) Nomination by Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 09:34, 12 Arche 2015 (UTC)
For:
  • [nods] an unexpected twist. Decks.png ~ Good tidings! ~ 09:34, 12 Arche 2015 (UTC)
  • I had to defrog my frog-infested pineapple to vote, bat certaini! XY007 T C 01:04, 14 Arche 2015 (UTC)
Against:
Comments:


Richard Dawkins (cult leader) (vote)

Score: 2.5 (6-3.5) Nomination by Mars Cadbury (talk) 17:01, 23 Jeremy 2014 (UTC)
For:
  • Seems ok enough. -− Flyingcat (meow?)fr: 23:26, 9 Farbleum 2014 (UTC)
  • Despite the fact that I was one of the contributors to this thing, I think it's suitable for framing and front page insertion. Is there an anime version? LAR Adriator-Gruntled.png 16:57, 17 Arche 2014 (UTC)
  • i wrote it. therefore god does not exist --Nerd42 (talk) 20:14, 7 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
  • Really wekk done 87.64.160.159 14:21, 8 Farbleum 2015 (UTC)
  • Well dunn. --(BKYE) Lord Sophia of Fruitland (babble)
  • Definitely very good. XY007 T C 23:04, 21 Farbleum 2015 (UTC)
Against:
  • 87.64.84.205 11:34, 22 Aym 2014 (UTC)
  • Negative one from me. I disliked most of it. The end was silly in a good way. the rest was meh--Duckwiki2.png|Fonchezzz| Quacking| 15:12, 23 Aym 2014 (UTC)
  • Nah, didn't get a single laugh out of me. Monkey-butler.jpg Sincerely, islandmonkey - go speak 08:22, 24 Aym 2014 (UTC)
  • No, siree. I'm all for satire, but this just wasn't amusing enough to justify its clear axe to grind. --T3 04:03, 7 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)
Comments:
  • This article is in the category 'Poking fun at people you idolize for stupid reasons'. Does this not mean that the axe it grinds is in fact negative space, or something of the sort? Things can be made of negative space and have a very definite shape, though. There are also two categories on it that are red as a sunset, which I would remove if I were not uncertain of their unfailure to not serve a negative purpose. I think my nots got knotted. -− Flyingcat (meow?)fr: 19:00, 7 Jumbly 2014 (UTC)